What do hotel star ratings really mean?

If you had to choose between a 5-star hotel and a 2-star hotel, which would you pick?

It’s likely that most of us would opt for the first option if a 5-star hotel wasn’t so much more expensive than the second.

Considering all the amenities that high-end hotels offer, some might conclude that the price is worth it, while others might prefer standard hotels that provide just the basics.

This post may contain affiliate links. This means if you buy something after clicking on a link, I’ll earn a few pennies to help me keep creating posts like this, at no extra cost to you!

To make a decision, it’s a good idea to look at the pros and cons of each option and choose the one that you believe is most suitable for you and your family.

5-Star hotel

Huatulco in Mexico, for example, has a selection of 5-star hotels that offer an unparalleled luxury and comfort experience. Among the top choices is Huatulco Barcelo, which comes highly recommended.

This hotel, along with others in the same category, guarantees an elevated experience, often exceeding your expectations. It’s an all-inclusive, and this ‘all-inclusive’ label will pleasantly surprise you, along with its many positive aspects.

Advantages

Luxury facilities. The 5-star hotels in Huatulco boast top-class amenities such as infinity pools, well-equipped gyms, luxury spas, gourmet restaurants, and direct access to private beaches.
Personalised attention. From the moment you arrive, the staff ensure you feel welcomed and well-attended at all times. Services like 24-hour concierge, butler, and private transfers are common in these hotels.
Elegant rooms. The rooms are designed to the highest standards of comfort and style, offering spectacular views, high-quality beds, luxury amenities, and in some cases, even private pools.
Variety of activities. These hotels often offer a wide range of activities and entertainment within their premises, such as water sports, yoga classes, live shows, and personalized excursions.
Prime location. Many 5-star hotels are situated in the best areas of Huatulco, offering easy access to beaches, restaurants, and tourist attractions.

Disadvantages

High cost. The main disadvantage of staying in a 5-star hotel is the price. These hotels are considerably more expensive, making them unaffordable for all budgets.
More formal atmosphere. While luxury is attractive, some travellers may find the atmosphere in these hotels too formal or rigid, especially if they are looking for a more relaxed and casual vacation.
High expectations. When paying a premium price, expectations naturally rise, which can lead to disappointment if any aspect of the service or facilities doesn’t meet the standard.

2-Star hotel

1-star hotels are generally among the worst, so travellers usually opt for at least a 2-star hotel for a simpler and more economical experience.

Though more modest, these hotels provide the essentials for a comfortable stay and allow visitors to enjoy Huatulco without overspending.

Options include Hotel Plaza Tangolunda and Hotel Cruz del Sur, which offer basic but clean and well-maintained rooms.

Advantages

Significant savings. 2-star hotels are much more affordable, allowing you to allocate more of your budget to other activities during the trip, such as excursions, dining out, or shopping.
Relaxed atmosphere. These hotels often have a more relaxed and casual atmosphere, ideal for travellers looking for a hassle-free stay without too many formalities.
Close to local culture. Being located in more traditional or less touristy areas, these options give you the chance to be closer to the everyday life of Huatulco residents, providing a more authentic experience.
Flexible stay. They generally have more flexible policies regarding check-in and check-out times, as well as basic services that can be better adapted to the needs of each traveler, especially if traveling solo.

Disadvantages

Limited services. Unlike 5-star hotels, 2-star hotels offer fewer services and amenities, meaning you may have to do without more than you think.
Basic facilities. The facilities are simpler and less modern, which might not satisfy travelers looking for a more sophisticated or luxurious environment.
Less privileged location. These hotels are usually located in less central areas or farther from the main tourist attractions, meaning it will take you longer to get around.

Which one will you choose?

After evaluating both sides of each option, you likely have a clearer picture that will help you make a decision based on your needs and preferences.

Remember, if you choose one, you can always change your mind and try the other alternative, and from your experience, decide where you’d prefer to stay.