Does being married make you a better parent? If the latest government report is to be believed it does. According to a study for the Department of Work and Pensions married parents are more likely to raise a βsuccessful familyβ, and children brought up by lone or unmarried parents do worse.
As a (happily) married mum of two I was aghast when I read the story, so I can only imagine how single and unmarried parents must be feeling. What a slap in the face for all the hours youβve worked, the clubs and activities youβve saved up for, the treats youβve gone without and sacrifices youβve made in order to give your children the best start you possibly can.
Of course the suggestion that married couples make better parents is nothing new, but what annoys me about βreportsβ like this is the sweeping generalisations they make. When you delve into the detail it turns out the researchers looked at just 40,000 families β thatβs 40,000 out of the UKβs 18.7 million families. So 0.2%.
Misery Guts says the results will be βweightedβ to make themΒ representative of theΒ population as a whole, but to me this smacks of the study that decided nurseries can afford to increase funded childcare for three and four year olds from 15 hours a week to 30 with no extra funding from central governmentΒ after looking at nurseries mainlyΒ locatedΒ in the north of England, where the cost of living is less than the south.
They donβt say whether the families in this latest study were spread evenly throughout the UK and from a variety of socioeconomic backgrounds, or whether they were from one specific location and therefore even less representative of the nation as a whole. Either way I sincerely hope theyβre not going to start drafting policy based on these findings.
But quite apart from all that, whatβs a βsuccessful familyβ when itβs at home? It depends on your definition of success. If BB and Little B reach adulthood with us all still on speaking terms and without any of us having killed each other or run away, Iβll consider that a success.
In my experience itβs often the seemingly βsuccessfulβ families who are actually the most dysfunctional ones, and surely itβs better to have two happy, single or unmarried, parents than two unhappy, married, ones.
Barak Obama, Madonna, Bradley Wiggins, John Lennon, JK Rowling, Angelina Jolie βΒ they were all raised by single parents and many of them have argued that being from a single parent family actually made them more driven.
Anyway, rant over. I better get back to being a βsuccessful parentβ. Which at this precise moment in time means extracting Little Bβs hand from the cat litter tray and stopping BB helping herself to chocolate biscuits.
Linking up with…
I agree, how can you judge a family on something so flimsy as the parents being married. As you so rightly point out it is nonsense. #bestandworst
It’s awful because some ‘lone’ parents are lone through no choice of their own (for example if they’ve suffered a bereavement) – how can that make them any worse as a parent?
Who writes these reports? And more so, who fills in the questionnaires? I’m a married parent and just thankful Henry is a happy little boy. And as a child of a single mum, I’m equally happy I was a happy little girl. I prefer those stats :0) #bestandworst Renee @peonieandme
This study seems so wishy washy – it’s not even clear how the research was carried out, whether it was questionnaires, or exam results, or some other measure of success. Crazy!
I haven’t read that report but I did roll my eyes when you referred to it. I’m an unmarried parent. Do I think a piece of paper and a wedding ring on my finger will constitute me being better at parenting? Do I balls!! Interesting post- thanks for sharing. #bestandworst
It sounds so ludicrous when you put it like that!!
Amen to that. Well said!! I come from a seemingly ‘successul’ family and I’m married with a little one myself, but my goodness, my family have had more than their share of dysfunction and issues. O truly admire single parents and wish my upbringing could have been different…..
That’s so interesting to hear! I admire single and lone parents too – I don’t know how they do it!x
This seems rather odd and it would be interesting to know more about the study. How it was done, who was surveyed and what definitions they used … No doubt the newspaper has picked up on one small part of it and ignored everything else!
I actually agree more with your definition of success. π
Well it’s interesting you should say that as I’ve looked at lots of newspaper articles covering the story and also the DW&P itself, and all are very vague on the nitty gritty detail. I shudder to think how much was spent on this!
Totally agree with you married,unmarried or whatever lots of good parents and bad ones these surveys annoy the hell out of me total rubbish never to be believed fantastic post.
Me too! And the danger is that people DO believe surveys like this – I think they do more harm than good!
Oops #bestandworst
Nahhh!! I think it’s down to the individuals themselves as to what makes them a good parent not down to being married but interesting post! Thanks for linking up #bestandworst
Yes I agree with you totally x
Be the best we can is the only way to go. I’ve been a bit of both while I’ve been a parent and only one thing has ever mattered, and that was my children. Silly to put anything else on the parenting side. Maybe there are some other areas we have to think a bit more about when we are lone parenting and its bloomin hard. We are all pretty creative so usually get over them hurdles very well:)
mainy – myrealfairy
#bestandworst
It’s good to hear from someone who has experienced both sides – thanks for sharing!x
I was brought up by my mum and she was single the entire time. She certainly had her foibles but she did a pretty good job. And what about all the parents in unhappy marriages together “for the kids sake”. How can that be better?! Bloody government statistics! #effitfridays
Yes precisely, surely unhappy married parents is a worse environment than happy single or unmarried ones…
How do they come up with this stuff??? It annoys me when they make big bold statements and that is all some people will read. They won’t read the detail behind it that show its such a small percentage!! So annoying x #picknmix
You know what they say – don’t believe the headline…
I hate sweeping generalisations like this – like you that annoys me as a married parent and I can’t imagine how much more it would annoy me if I wasn’t. Why on earth being married would make you a better parent is beyond me.
It annoyed me even though I’m a married parents too – urghh!!
Probably written by someone with no idea of the struggles a lot of us go through – married or not – to keep things balanced for our kids (oops hope I’m not guilty there of making a sweeping statement!). #SundayStars
It would be interesting to know exactly who wrote the study and what their background is!
Ugh, what is with these ridiculous studies? I’m not a married parent (though we are engaged) and I don’t think it has ANY standing whatsoever on my children. Some of the strongest people I know have come from single parent families! #sundaystars
Yes precisely, I’m with you there!
What a load of rubbish! (The ‘study’ not your post!) Why should something like that affect children? I mean yes, single parent family are a lot different to families where mum & dad are married. But does that make them worse?? Not at all. Also, I have 2 little ones, and I live with their dad. Engaged but not yet married, does this mean that when we do tie the knot, we will change how we parent??
Great post. Thanks for sharing π
Sarah xx
whimsialmumblings.blogspot.co.uk
Exactly, what about all those families who get married when the children have already come along! Like I said, this is such a sweeping generalisation!!
This angers me, sometimes I think they publish these things to piss people off. Let’s just all do our best!!! Xx
The research group was so small too – ridiculous!
Ooo what a controversial topic. I think you’ve made some really interesting points here – especially with the term ‘ successful’ – how can a family be successful? You could have a great job but be dying inside or you could have the best dressed children who are miserable. Great piece. #effitfriday
Yes that’s so true. I think everyone is far too judgemental!
I agree completely, what is a ‘successful parent’?! Success to me is getting us all ready in the morning, fed throughout the day and into bed without too much hassle in the evening! π we aren’t married (yet) but Mia is still a well rounded child who definitely doesn’t seem to be affected by us not being married! I think its another silly government idea to make us all feel like we aren’t quite doing enough still! π
#sundaysstars
Keeping everyone happy and fed definitely constitutes success – regardless of the marital status of the parents!
I don’t understand how you can judge “success” because surely success is different depending on who you speak to. Everyone has their own ideals and thoughts on what makes something successful and I’m not even sure it can be a term applied to families!!!
Hi Natalie, another government study made to make decent and hard working parents feel lousy. What relationship status has to do with anything is beyond me. Married or unmarried, single or not single, surely it’s the way a child is raised that matters.
And like you asked, what on earth is successful parenting? Most of us are just winging it until they leave home, happy and healthy (hopefully).
xx
I recently shared a meme which said ‘being an adult is mostly googling how to do stuff and feeling tired all the time’ – I think the same goes for parenting. Like you say, most of us are just winging it!!