Have you heard about the mum who live vlogged her birth and shared it with all and sundry – by which I mean more than 200,000 people – on Facebook and Channel Mum?
I kid you not, Sarah-Jayne Ljungstrom broadcast her labour from start to finish in not one, not two, but five separate vlogs as her baby ‘moved down the birth canal’.
As a fellow blogger I totally understand how all-consuming and compelling blogging can be, but is nothing sacred anymore?
Rest assured people, I will not be following in Sarah-Jayne’s footsteps when I give birth in a few weeks’ time, and here’s why.
10 reasons live vlogging birth is a terrible idea
1. Showing the world your foo-foo when you haven’t actually been able to see it yourself for the last few weeks – or months – is surely unadvisable. Trained medical staff are one thing – they’ve seen it all – but complete strangers? No no no no no.
2. No-one wants to picture you dilating. Admittedly Sarah-Jayne didn’t actually show off her foo-foo, but she did give viewers regular updates on how dilated she was. Who on earth wants to visualise that?
3. What if you throw up? As well as your neglected foo-foo, no-one wants to see you chucking up last night’s biriyani – or whatever you ate to try and get things going – either.
4. What if you wet yourself? You can try and pass it off as your water’s breaking, but we’ll all know the real truth.
5. What if you do a blow off? Or five? Anyone who’s had a baby will tell you there’s absolutely no controlling what goes on down there when things get serious, and like the puking no-one is going to want to hear you parp.
6. What if you do a poo? Or five? For the same reasons listed above this is a very real possibility, and while watching an unwitting dad-to-be with a net might be funny in films and in theory, it’s unlikely to be quite so amusing when broadcast through your Facebook or YouTube channel.
7. What if you say something you shouldn’t? Apart from swearing profusely, what if the gas and air sends you so ga-ga you say something you really shouldn’t. It’s not like you can unsay it if you’re live.
8. Think of your digital footprint. Do you really want a future boss or your bundle of joy’s future spouse able to access footage of you puffing, panting and parping your way through labour?
9. It’s taking things too far. No doubt live vlogging her birth has been brilliant for Sarah-Jayne’s stats, not to mention her social media profile, but really? When it comes to over-sharing this is surely it.
10. What will your new arrival say when they’re old enough to understand? You’re at risk of scarring them for life.
What do you think? Did you see any of Sarah-Jayne’s footage? Would you ever consider live vlogging your birth, or is it taking things a step too far?
Linking up with…
You are so right. I wouldn’t even think of capturing it with a camera never even mind vlogging it.
Me too! Even the camera coming out afterwards makes me shudder!!
I think it could be quite empowering, and in a way it’s normalising it for people, but I am to sure I am the one to be normalising or empowering it!
Emily Norris did it too, I didn’t see Sarah’s, but Emily’s was actually very good and actually not too graphic iykwim! #thelist
I haven’t come across Emily’s one – I will have a look! I just feel labour and birth should be a private thing, not something to be shared with all the world…
Each to their own I say. Maybe if people were more open about birth we wouldn’t all live in fear of it? So what if she did all of those things and broadcast it to the world? She’s giving birth to a baby, it’s real and raw and honest and I think all it should ever be is celebrated. Making women feel ashamed for something as amazing as birth (including all the normal bodily functions that may happen during) is just crazy. Share as much or as little as you like but don’t judge someone else for doing differently.
I disagree that we all live in fear of birth – I certainly don’t. I also don’t think her footage is real and raw and honest – it seems quite contrived to me. I guess we will have to agree to disagree on this one! Each to their own as you say!
This is an interesting one!! My instinct is yes: this is taking it too far!! And the digital footprint thing is a good point. But I am addicted to One Born Every Minute and could watch anything and everything about birth – it is so incredible. I’ve had 4 babies and each time it has been other-worldly and fantastical and private – I definitely wouldn’t want to share. All the best for your little one’s arrival! #thelist
I agree with you – and I find One Born compulsive viewing too!
Oh my word – I hadn’t heard about this! Crazy! I love One Born Every Minute and watched it avidly while I was pregnant, but I think that’s different because it isn’t live – it’s edited and so I assume the people involved have some sort of say if there are bits that they don’t want sharing. But no I don’t think streaming it all live is a good idea – I’d never feel I could show my face in public again! #TheListLinky
It seems to be quite a popular thing to do now – I certainly won’t be doing it though!
Some things are best left for the memory banks! 😉 My mummy had a waterbirth and there was all manner of things she’d rather not share…..especially online!! #TheListLinky
I had a water birth too last time and ditto! Some things are best left unshared!
I haven’t seen Sarah’s vlogs but now i’m curious to watch it. personally I don’t think I would ever consider filming my labour and delivery maybe just write a post about it or do a sit down chatty video but not a vlog # KCACOLS
Yes! A vlog afterwards is a better idea! But lots of people seem to be embracing Sarah-Jayne’s approach too!
No way would I want to have vlogged my two labours, post birth mummy and baby photos are bad enough! But if others want to do it I guess that’s their call, not sure why it needs to broadcast on the Internet though and not just recorded for personal viewing.xx #kcacols
I’m with you – when I look back at those post-birth photos I never want to share ones I am in!
I vlogged my birth with my youngest, but it wasn’t live – it’s edited and you don’t see anything you wouldn’t see (probably less) than on OBEM. It’s a beautiful thing to capture, and I’m SO glad I did it. I know I watched loads of videos when I was pregnant, so why not do one myself? I’ve only had positive feedback from it x
That’s so interesting to hear! Hats off to you for actually being able to do something else while in labour!!
Oh I’m not sure about this one. I really enjoyed the live updates on instagram, although I didn’t watch the videos on facebook. I’ve never really thought about the over sharing element though, and I would definitely never do it myself, I wont even speak on my instagram stories as I cant bear to hear my own voice! x #KCACOLS
That’s so interesting! I haven’t done an Instagram story yet – I’m just getting to grips with vlogging…
I’m surprised this has been done! I spent 90% of my labour completely naked writhing in agony like a dying slung! I’m surprised my OH can still look at me let alone 200,000 random people of facebook!
Good call on giving that one a miss!
#KCACOLS
Yes I’ve been there, done that and got the T-shirt too! I know just what you mean!
I think people that do vlog their live birth are incredibly brave. It is certainly not something I would EVER do for all the above reasons lol
I know some people are really into the idea but I’m with you!
Totally agree. Also. Why would people watch it. Surely if you want to watch labour you’d watch the edited version on one born every minute. Bonkers! #KCACOLS
I guess like One Born it makes compulsive viewing! Not for me though…
I’ve thought about it, I planned on filmed some of my labour to created an edited and put together vlog at the end, with completely control of what went into it. But when the time came I didn’t even reach of the camera once. But I would think about it again next time. Probably not live vlogging though. Live social media updates maybe if there was an audience for it though.
I know what you mean about forgetting about the camera – everything you planned goes out of the window doesn’t it!
Oh gosh I didn’t realise that this was a ‘thing’ now. I’m sure the debate will go on. I last gave birth quite a while (11 years) ago and it wasn’t heard of then! Thanks so much for linking up at #KCACOLS. Hope you come back again next Sunday
I think it is becoming a thing – so many people seem to be doing it now…
Oh gosh I didn’t realise that this was a ‘thing’ now. I’m sure the debate will go on. I last gave birth quite a while (11 years) ago and it wasn’t heard of then! Thanks so much for linking up at #KCACOLS. Hope you come back again next Sunday
I saw this on FB, but I didn’t watch. I can’t watch OBEM let alone anything like this. I remember watching Robbie Williams little videos while his wife was in labour, it was funny but that is my limit x #KCACOLS
Yes I remember Robbie’s too – he can come into my delivery room any day!!
Filming it in general seems like a really bad idea in general, let alone sharing it online. We didn’t even want to take pictures until Snappy was born and I sure as hell wasn’t making notes for the blog post about his birth. #kcacols
Me too! I remember about an hour after ours were born thinking we ought to get the camera out now!
To be honest, I love watching them. I would have loved someone to have recorded me BUT not live!
#KCACOLS
Really? I’d absolutely hate it!!
Ah just saw this about my live labour! Super interesting to read the comments; I totally agree with all your reasons above for not sharing active labour and probably I did them all – ha ha :-). It was my third labour so I knew what to expect and only vlogged at moments I was totally fine and well to do so; actually all before I went into hospital and then when I got home with baby. I didn’t film the active labour as wouldn’t be something I’d watch back – ha ha! Though I do kind of wish I had the moment of her coming out and them telling me her gender as it was so special and of course we kept that moment just for us and I’ll never forget it. I love shows like One Born and think labour is something that should be celebrated and demystified; amongst women we talk about our labours all the time and it’s therapeutic and helps prepare us for what’s so so hard. So this was all I did; just maybe a more modern version of it 🙂 xxx