Brace yourselves: this is going to be a ranty one.
Have you heard the one about new mums being offered shopping vouchers in exchange for breastfeeding? I kid you not, that’s the latest initiative hit upon by the so-called experts in a bid to improve breastfeeding rates in the UK. And it makes me SO mad.
Firstly, the scheme places emphasis and blame for poor breastfeeding rates on us mums as usual; secondly, it completely ignores the multitude of reasons breastfeeding rates in this country are so low and thirdly, who comes up with these ideas? I’d be willing to bet money on it being people who have never breastfed – or supported a partner who has.
The trial cost a whopping £460,000 to conduct and gave new mums a £40 voucher if their baby was still receiving breastmilk at two days, 10 days, six weeks, three months and six months old. And if you ask me that £460,000 could have been far better spent elsewhere.
Why shopping vouchers for breastfeeding makes me SO mad!
How about spending the £460,000 on funding lactation consultants to help new mums struggling to get to grips with breastfeeding on hospital wards?
How about spending the money on cutting NHS waiting times to have issues like tongue tie resolved?
How about redirecting it into maternity allowance, allowing breastfeeding mamas to stay at home until they’re ready to return to work, instead of being forced back sooner than they otherwise might?
How about offering employers £40 vouchers for supporting breastfeeding mums in the work place two days, 10 days, six weeks, three months and six months after they return to work?
And how about offering cafe, shop and restaurant owners incentives for creating breastfeeding-friendly environments?
The thing is, the vouchers-for-breastfeeding trial has been hailed a success after breastfeeding rates rose from 31.7% to 37.9% among those who took part. But I’d also be willing to bet the results would be the same – if not better – if things liks breastfeeding support services and breastfeeding in the workplace were improved.
But what do I know? I’m just a mum who endured 10 days of torturous tongue tie owing to NHS waiting times and gave up a dream job so I could exclusively breastfeed three babies (insert eye roll emoji here).
What do you think? Does the vouchers-for-breastfeeding scheme sound like a good idea to you, or does the idea make you mad like me? I’d love to hear your thoughts!
I wholeheartedly agree with you. The money could definitely be spent in other better ways to help women breastfeed.
I came home from the Birth centre breastfeeding pretty well. But then my baby started cluster feeding like crazy and i knew she still wasn’t getting what she needed even though my health visitor insisted she was.
I spent weeks struggling to feed a hungry baby and eventually introduced formula to top up the breast milk. All the while feeling so much pressure and judgement for using formula.
#MMBC
Well said you! Agree with every word!!! Why do women and mums have to have guilt piled on them at every turn when all most of us need is a bit of support to be bloody amazing in every way #MMBC
That is so wrong! I couldn’t breastfeed with my first and that would have really made me feel like a failure! You are right the money could be spent on better things!
This is such a strange idea! Talk about being spent in the wrong place, and massively alienating a whole other group of women who for whatever reason don’t or can’t breastfeed. But because, hey, that’s okay too! #ItsOK
It’s crazy isn’t it, they don’t seem to understand that tons of women who don’t breasteed desperately want to but just can’t get the support to do it. #itsok
It’s absolutely ridiculous. They should just cut mothers some slack! We know the statistics and we have our baby’s wellbeing at heart, but also our own sanity. They need a new rhetoric. honestly.
#itsok
Wow! I honestly wonder about the type of person who thought up this campaign. Honestly one of the few things that got me through being able to breastfeed for a year plus was having an incredible breastfeeding support group round the corner to me. Sadly no longer running. The funding should be spent on support groups and having women like those who ran my group, working in the hospitals supporting mums in those early days when we need it most. I don’t blame you for wanting to have a rant. These kind of campaigns are really thought up by people who have experienced the situation first hand.
Thanks for linking up to #KCACOLS
I must say I haven’t heard of this, but as you say, much better places to spends that money. I was lucky and found breastfeeding easy and convenient, that would have just been free money to me for something I would have chosen to do anyway. #KCACOLS
I was very lucky and found breastfeeding relatively easy but that was because I was extremely lucky that in the first few days I was able to spend a couple of hours with a really amazing midwife who sat with me and supported me and my son until we had it down to a fine art. I would absolutely agree with you that the money would be better spent on lactation consultants to support new Mums in a caring way! #KCACOLS
I totally agree with you. your ideas would be much better ways to spend the money and much more useful and beneficial! #KCACOLS
Well, I’d have been screwed. Breastfeeding just didn’t happen for me. Not because I didn’t try. Not because I didn’t get all the fancy equipment. Just didn’t produce milk. So I would have been mad about this too. Waste of money. #KCACOLS
I had not heard of this initiative but I am outraged as you. I think you need to send this post over to whoever is running the scheme. I appreciate it may be well intentioned but as you say so many better ways that money could be spent. #KCACOLS
I agree that this is a crazy idea. As you say, there are plenty of much better ways to help increase breastfeeding rates. #kcacols
Oh for goodness sake! What will they come up with next. Totally agree with you the money would be better invested in services which support women to breast feed – if they choose to and are able to. Not only is it not putting money where it’s needed most, but it’s putting pressure on women and making those who bottle feed feel guilty.
#KCACOLS
This is the stupidist thing I’ve heard all well, and I’ve been on twitter this week. #kcacols